Paradise Island, Bahamas: Where to Stay and Why It's Worth It
Where to stay on Paradise Island comes down to one choice: the harbor side, looking across the water to Nassau, or the Atlantic side along Cabbage Beach. Either way, the island is worth it if you want long white-sand beaches with a capital city across a bridge, rather than the remoteness of an Out Island.
Our Paradise Island page currently lists one home, and we'll come to it below. First, here's how the island is laid out and who it suits.
Paradise Island Is Small, Connected and Across the Harbor From Nassau
Paradise Island is a long, narrow island lying just off the north shore of New Providence, with Nassau Harbour running between them. Two bridges connect it to the main island, so crossing to Nassau for dinner or a morning of history takes no boat and no planning.
The island was once known as Hog Island and took its current name in the early 1960s, when it was developed as a resort destination. That history still shows. Paradise Island today is polished and built-up, with large resorts, a marina, a golf course and private estates sharing a small footprint.
Arrival is through Lynden Pindling International Airport on New Providence, and the island is reached by road across the harbor bridges. It's a simple trip, which is part of the island's appeal for shorter stays.
Where to Stay on Paradise Island: Harbor Side or Atlantic Side
The island's two shores feel quite different, and the right one depends on how you'd like to spend your days.
The Harbor Side
The southern shore faces Nassau Harbour and the city beyond. Here the water is sheltered, boats come and go, and evenings bring the lights of Nassau across the water. It suits anyone who likes to watch the harbor's traffic from the terrace.
The Atlantic Side and Cabbage Beach
The northern shore faces the open Atlantic, and its centerpiece is Cabbage Beach, a long sweep of pale sand. Facing the ocean, this shore is more exposed to wind and swell than the harbor, and it's where you'll want to be for long beach walks.
The Western Tip
At the island's western end, a historic lighthouse marks the entrance to Nassau Harbour. It's a pleasing end point for a walk or a view from the water, and a reminder of how long this harbor has mattered.
Paradise Island, Nassau or an Out Island?
Paradise Island isn't the only way to see the Bahamas, so it helps to compare it with the obvious alternatives. Here's how we'd match each base to a traveler:
- Paradise Island suits families who want beaches and activities in one place, couples on a shorter trip, and anyone who wants Nassau's dining and history close at hand.
- New Providence and Nassau suit travelers who want a working city, colonial streets and forts, and easy access to the airport.
- Exuma and the Out Islands suit anyone who wants quiet water, sandbars and boat days, and doesn't mind a domestic flight to reach them.
Two of these combine well in one luxury villa holiday. A few nights on Paradise Island and a longer stretch in Exuma is a natural pairing.
What the Villa Experience Is Like on Paradise Island
On Paradise Island, a private home gives you something the island's large resorts can't: your own grounds, your own pool and a quiet terrace, with the island's beaches and Nassau still close at hand.
The one home on our Paradise Island page is Villa Sul Mare, a tropical pavilion-style home on an acre of private land within a gated estate. Its private backyard leads to the harbor, and patios and terraces spread around the heated pool, a lily pond and the waterfront. A covered pergola makes a shaded spot for meals outdoors, and there's a hot tub, an outdoor shower and a ping pong table for slower afternoons.
Our listing places Cabbage Beach about 1.1 km away and Lynden Pindling International Airport about 21.9 km away. Guests have private beach access through the estate's club at Cabbage Beach. A butler, a property manager and daily housekeeping are among the listed services, and both a daily continental breakfast and a private chef dinner can be arranged.
Two Exuma Homes for a Quieter Stay
If Paradise Island feels too busy for the trip you have in mind, Great Exuma offers the opposite: low cays, shallow water and a slower pace. These two homes sit there, a domestic flight away from Nassau.
Villa Exuma overlooks the Moriah Harbour area in Hartswell, where small islands and shallow water keep the sea calm. Our listing places Moriah Harbour Cay National Park about 600 meters away. The property has a private dock, a pool and an outdoor shower, plus kayaks, a paddleboard and snorkeling gear for the sandbars and mangrove channels, and daily housekeeping, a butler and a property manager are among its services.
Aqua Sound is a beachfront home on Great Exuma, about 8.8 km from George Town according to our listing. Glass doors span the living and dining rooms to frame the bay, a terrace runs the full length of the ocean side, and the pool sits within a private tropical garden. The home is also wheelchair accessible.
So, Is Paradise Island Worth It?
Yes, for the right trip. Paradise Island is worth it when you want beach time and city time from the same base, with minimal travel once you land. It's especially good for shorter stays, families who want plenty to do, and travelers who enjoy a polished, lively setting.
Part of that value lies across the bridge. From a Paradise Island base, Nassau's colonial streets, Parliament Square, the Queen's Staircase and the old forts above the harbor are all within easy reach, and in winter the Junkanoo parades fill downtown on Boxing Day and New Year's Day. It makes mixing beach days with history unusually simple.
It's less suited to anyone seeking solitude. The island is developed and compact, and its resorts draw a crowd. If seclusion is the goal, look to Exuma, and treat Paradise Island as a stopover or skip it altogether.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where should we stay on Paradise Island?
Choose the harbor side if you want sheltered water, boats and views of Nassau, or the Atlantic side if long beach walks on Cabbage Beach matter most. Villa Sul Mare sits on the harbor with Cabbage Beach about 1.1 km away according to our listing, giving you a little of both.
Is Paradise Island connected to Nassau?
Yes. Two bridges link Paradise Island to New Providence across Nassau Harbour, so you can drive between them easily. Arrival is through Lynden Pindling International Airport on New Providence.
Is Paradise Island better than Exuma?
They suit different trips. Paradise Island offers beaches, activities and Nassau close at hand, while Exuma is quieter and centered on the water. The two also pair well in a single trip.
Choosing Your Base
Renting a villa in the Caribbean, or in the Bahamas just to the north, is about matching the home to the trip. We've placed guests in vacation rentals in the Caribbean since 1979, and every home we offer is personally inspected before it joins our collection, with a pre-arrival check before each stay.
Whether you settle at Villa Sul Mare on the harbor or head south to Villa Exuma or Aqua Sound, our Paradise Island page is a good place to begin. When you're ready, we're here to help.
Our Destinations
